Search
Tuesday, October 07, 2008 ..:: Forums ::.. Register  Login
 VCFA Forum Minimize

 
  Forum  Discussions  General  Black Marlin on Fly's
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 7/2/2008 8:26 AM
  Boats
13 posts
No Ranking


Black Marlin on Fly's 
On TV the other day.

Trend Barta was Black Marlin Fishing down south. Good detail on his 14 wt fly rod & Rig. Fly was a tube style without the tube, rigged to slide on the 100 # shock tippet. Double hooked. Then it went to a IGFA class tippet then to some braid. Finished with a butt section that had a foot of Orange braid before loop to loop to the fly line. He set the drag on the fly reel at 2 lbs so the fish could not break off on strike.

They trolled and teased up a big Black. Trend pitched the fly out 30 feet or so and the Marlin took it. Next part amazed me. He stuck the fish then the Capt backed down fast, Barta reeled like crazy all 30 feet when the Orange braid was inside the tip top he broke the fish off. Whole thing lasted about 30 seconds. They said it was a legal IGFA catch and release because the leader was inside the rods guides. Thats why they use Orange they can see the leader.

I am sure all of this fits IGFA rules, but would you fly to Central America to pitch a bait crank 30 feet and break the fish off ? No doubt the Captian has it all down pat, but the sport who paid the bill did not get much out of the experence. My opinion is Capt Trend pulled off a stunt, that's all. It's not fly fishing.

Boats
 
New Post 7/2/2008 11:16 AM
  ronflyfish
60 posts
No Ranking


Re: Black Marlin on Fly's 

Ego will sometimes cloud your thinking!

In my opinion it is not considered fly fishing. Rules say trolling is illegal and boat must be out of gear at time of presentation and during retrieve.  If he did it as you say then it is not a legal IGFA catch.

 
New Post 7/2/2008 3:11 PM
  Boats
13 posts
No Ranking


Re: Black Marlin on Fly's 

Actually he followed the rules to the letter, took the boat ouf of gear when casting.  She still had way on but not in gear.  Don't know about that fine point,   I guess it is fly fishing since he cast a fly and the Marlin took it.   What I wonder is can you call this a catch and release. All he did was stick the fish on a short line. reel the slack in and break him off.  No matter what IGFA says this is not a release in my eyes

Just a stunt

Boats

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Forum  Discussions  General  Black Marlin on Fly's

 Print   
Copyright Virginia Coastal Fly Anglers 2008   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement
DotNetNuke® is copyright 2002-2008 by DotNetNuke Corporation